Why You Must Experience Chawls In Mumbai Atleast Once In Your Lifetime

WHAT WERE THE FOCAL POINTS?

HOW SETTLEMENT OF DWELLING HAPPENED IN THE CITY?

HOW WAS THE LIFE IN COLONIAL & POST COLONIAL ERA?

WHAT WAS SCENARIO OF CHAWLS IN MUMBAI?


I still remember in my architecture college days when we were getting ready for one of the trophies for NASA while doing the case study of chawls I learned how important these structures were to the urban fabric of the city. These were the spread outs from the focal points (Mills). Also, not to forget about the social aspect of these chawls. In India where you have so many festivals of which many are where the whole society is involved. The best part of these chawls was the courtyards which developed a strong cultural background amongst the tenants. Be it festivals, social events or just a Sunday morning cricket match it had a strong emotional value, and by urbanization we are losing these cultural pockets leaving us with just the nostalgia of such spaces.


So around the 1850s a lot of thing was happening in and around Bombay. In 1845 the seven islands coalesced into a single landmass by the Hornby Vellard Project. In 1853, we had our first Indian railway opened which stretched from Bombay to thane. In 1854, we had our first cotton mill in Bombay.in 1863, the British orchestrated the construction of a robust and affordable transportation system of local railways. In 1872, the addition of trams, trains and bus routes throughout the city allowed people to move into the suburbs post-independence. Due to unplanned settlements, overcrowded and unsanitary conditions, Plague broke out in 1896. In response to those problems the City Improvement Trust was established to open new localities for settlement and to erect dwellings for the artisan classes.

As Bombay prospered as an industrial and commercial center, many prestigious urban projects were undertaken in the colonial (European/ British) parts of the city in an attempt to mirror the ‘spatial reconfiguration of the 19th-century European cities. It appears that the large parks, monuments, bungalows and wide streets of south Bombay came to be precisely because the poor lived and continue to live n chawls and ‘slums’, area without any civic amenities.

According to the 1849 census, Europeans were only 1 percent of the population, but they lived in the spacious fort area, while nearly two-fifths of the population lived in the crowded areas immediately north of the Fort. The death rate in such dense areas was four times that in the Fort area. The census of 1911 found that 80 percent of Bombay’s population lived in chawls.

Sketch by Ruchir Lad on "Chawls in Mumbai"
Sketch by Ruchir Lad on “Chawls in Mumbai”

In 1890 when the city boasted of 70 textile mills, it was estimated that around 100,000 people slept on roads or footpaths. Continued industrialization throughout the early 20th century caused exponential increases in population and contributed to the continued growth of chawls and slums beyond the wall.

According to Adarkar, Pendse and Finkelstein (2011), living conditions and the fate of working-class dwellings are closely related to urbanization in Mumbai. Industrial land during the early 1900s was inexpensive due to its proximity to the outskirts of the fort area. Both workers and employers needed to have workforce housing within an accessible distance from the industry. It is estimated that at one time, almost 75% of workers lived within a 15-minute walk to their workplace. Incidentally, many textile mills arranged for some social commodities such as bathing areas and barbershops with their premises.

The chawls were originally permanent housing for male workers and were either mill-owned, constructed by Bombay (Mumbai) Development Department, or privately owned as an investment property. The Chawl was meant for both blue- and white-collar workers, though they lived in different buildings. Each Chawl formed an unofficial “neighborhood” in and of itself, where occupants were typically people pf the same origins, dialects, occupations, or classes. This organization has remained the same over the years. As the population gradually increased, timber and brick chawls soon became overcrowded and slum settlements began to develop into temporary clustered units.

chawl

Dwivedi and Mehrotra (1995) describe how these overcrowded conditions made renting space more difficult. This difficulty led Chawl owners to seek creative ways to accommodate new members or migrants, such as partitioning single rooms, installing folding wooden planks to serve as bunk beds and constructing mezzanine lofts for storage and sleeping.

Further, the British introduction of reinforced cement concrete (RCC) as a construction material dramatically increased the rate at which developers could build chawls, demonstrating how Indian and British contractors actively promoted these living conditions. Though cement was imported initially, the readily available sand for concrete mixture paired with cheap labor in Mumbai made RCC an ideal solution to the local housing shortage.

According to Adarkar, Pendse and Finkelstein (2011) during colonial rule, the mill-owned tenement housing was quite unpopular, though considered to be the most convenient accommodation at the time. Adarkar (2011) writes, “Absence from work could not be easy if you stayed in one of these chawls. The owners could (and did) threaten to cut off electricity and water supply to the chawls if the workers were on strike, particularly what was termed ‘illegal strikes’.

rupali gupte prasad shetty propositions to see cities 17-638
Rupali Gupte Prasad Shetty, Propositions to see cities 17-638

The overcrowded scenario of the chawl, with its bare minimum civic amenities, would become a reference for the layouts of slum dwellings. Similar to chawls, slums during colonial rule were also an outcome of severe housing shortages throughout the city. Lack of housing led new laborers to construct dwellings near their places of work, forming a network of huts and sheds without any civic amenities. These slums neighborhoods were symbolic of the surplus of cheap labor: laborer’s housing needs were neither supported by their employers nor the state; thus residents, viewed as dispensable, were under constant pressure of eviction.

Indeed, during the 1890s with the addition of 70 textile mills in the city, it was estimated that around one million people slept on roads or footpaths. In the 1940s with the end of World War II and amid India’s independence and partition – Mumbai experienced yet another influx of migrants and refugees who would find themselves living in slums and pavement dwellings. The census of 1911 shows that 69% of the population lived in one-room dwellings; by the 1930s an average of around four people lived in each tenement, with over two million tenements throughout the city. Within this context slums during the colonial era were intended to be only temporary squatter settlements.

Unlike the worker-occupied chawls of the 1900s, post-colonial chawls are occupied by families. While workers had little incentive to convert these dwellings into homes, families make continuous efforts to transform their units into a habitable living space. After moving into the chawls families gradually invest in improvements that display qualities of performance and stability. Common spaces such as corridors staircases, courtyards and roofs change with the needs of the occupants.


This was a fun collaboration with Ruchir Lad. Thank you for the sketches. You can check his Instagram for more such sketches. Instagram – archi_theatre

These are a series blog so if you are not following anything is because you haven’t read from the start Click here

Don’t forget to like, comment, follow and share it with your friends

For more such cool stuff follow me on social media

For business inquiry: armohsinsheikh@outlook.com

UNTIL THEN, STAY TUNED & STAY SAFE


SOURCES & REFERENCES USED:

Mariam Dossal, Theatre of Conflict, City of Hope: Mumbai, Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2010, P. 198

Prashant Kidambi, making of an India Metropolis: Colonial Governance & Public Culture in Bombay 1890-1920, Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2007, p.38.

Neera Adarkar, Sandeep Pendse, Maura Finkelstein

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/271826671_The_Chawls_of_Mumbai_Galleries_of_Life/link/54d2377c0cf25017917d9226/download

Prasad Shetty, “Ganga Building Chronicles,” The Chawls of Mumbai: Galleries of Life, (Gurgaon: Imprintone, 2011), 61

Mehta, “The Terrain of Home,” 83.

The Chawl neighborhoods of Mumbai – Neera Adarkar

http://southasia.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/shared/events/21st_Century_Indian_City/Panel_6-Neera_Adarkar_2.pdf

Kaiwan Mehta, “The terrain of home and within Urban Neighbourhoods (A case of the Bombay Chawls),” The Chawls of Mumbai: galleries of life, (Gurgaon: ImprintOne, 2011), 61.

18 thoughts on “Why You Must Experience Chawls In Mumbai Atleast Once In Your Lifetime

  1. Nice…
    I would love to be there..
    This time when I was there in mumbai I went to Goregaon west there is my frnd whom I met in a local train during my intership he lives in a colony somewhere in Goregaon west near masjid in Om sai colony
    There I saw the actual Chawl
    It was totally different for me to experience… and the most important part which i observed was the concord among the residents…

    Liked by 3 people

  2. There are chawls too in Lagos my base too. We call them “face me, I face you” houses. And they are usually occupied by very low income earners.
    I don’t know how they would compare to the ones you described in Mumbai.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. I guess in every part of the world there would be a space where a high income person woukd stay and also a low income person to stay. Somewhere we call it chawls and somewhere face me, i face you houses. Its just the micro part of the macro setting of settlement we are in. Like the unsolved rubiks cube in which not all colors ae same but together.

      Like

  3. Reblogged this on The Foreign Correspondent: A Site of "Revealing Interviews" of a Foreign Correspondent, the Journalist and Writer and commented:
    Hi AR
    Thanks for the follow and likes.
    if you want to follow me, go to
    https://craigsbooks.wordpress.com/2019/09/18/craigs-list-of-blogs-about-300-of-them-at-wordpress/
    (to find one or two of interest…perhaps)
    and/or https://www.facebook.com/craig.lock.31
    +
    https://www.facebook.com/Uplift-Encourage-and-Inspire-479972392393133/
    # Though my family and close friends say it would be far more entertaining with a video-camera* in the “real world”, rather than in cyberspace!)
    * By the way, do they still make them in today’s ever-faster changing world..or is it all done with mobile phones?
    (get with the times now,”luddite”* c – it should be a smart phone)
    * or so I was often called by my “my techno-geek” friend, Bill (“the gonk”)
    “total non-techno” c (who doesn’t possess a mobile phone, after a rather eventful’ experience some years back, whilst trying to walk, talk and chew gum at the same time) #
    The impossible we do immediately; however miracles take a little longer!
    * (You may think I’m joking, but just ask my friends!)
    Who says men can’t multi-task!
    Men…Some Mothers Do ‘Ave ‘Em!
    “You will do foolish things, but do them with enthusiasm.”
    – Colette (nice name for a girl, btw)
    http://www.craigsquotes.woespress.com
    All the best with your blog
    Shared by “early bird” (very) * craig
    * my “best” time (by far)
    “Information and Inspiration Distributer, Incorrigible Encourager and People-builder” *
    * not bridges (thank goodness)!
    Well my family and friends say I’m “safest” just writing and sharing
    Still
    Driven to share, uplift, encourage and (perhaps even) inspire
    PPS
    “Live each day as if it’s your last…
    and one day you’ll be right!
    Don’t worry about the world ending today…
    it’s already tomorrow in scenic and tranquil ‘little’ New Zealand

    Liked by 2 people

  4. The “chawl” is new to me, but not so different from the high-rise housing for the urban poor in the US which dates from the 1950s. That style — often as high as 20 stories — has been abandoned here in favor of small single family homes. The thinking is that tenants who have little stake in such a large structure will not take steps to keep it in good order. (This may or may not be true.) The large structures are, also, difficult to police making them vulnerable to drug trafficking and gangs.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I totally agree on the maintenance part of the building is at stake in these kind of settlements . Also, i like the way you can relate this in your own context gives me more exposure to learn similar situations in the world. Thanks for commenting

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.